No free trade without free movement.
47
snowflakesdownvotes waowTwo explanations for downvotes:
- The core argument “If you aren’t anti-capitalist, you’re actually the same as a MAGA ethnonationalist” is deliberately divisive, and people don’t like that.
- This is a shit posting community, and some people might not like scold posts.
I personally just think the borders are immoral. I should be free to go from the United States to Canada or Mexico without having to stop and get butt fingered by a border patrol agent or whatever.
Removed by mod
Yeah 'cuz it’s like, then what do you think of refugees…
Just people who don’t speak any local language lacking transferable skills probably some trauma, but they’re humans in need.
No, I’m talking in their economic language because that’s how you justify policy in the neoliberal hell government that we have, like it or not.
Obviously the “Hey, they’re people, duh” approach isn’t going to work in a system fundamentally built to destroy humanity.
You can’t reform the system
We can make the system more liveable while we prepare for the revolution and maybe even make the revolution easier; the world is not black and white and you must do multiple things at once to succeed.
You can definitely do two things at once, but if you’re doing one thing that’s going against the other things then your results may vary
Has that ever worked in the long term?
The answer is no borders
Careful, you’ll get a lot of “socialists” outing themselves as bog standard liberals with this one.
These posts are serving as filters and I’m here for it 😛
while he may be heartless, he’s still right, and if you get the right public policy out of it, I’ll take it. https://www.economist.com/the-world-if/2017/07/13/a-world-of-free-movement-would-be-78-trillion-richer
Yup, I’ve used this argument to win over conservative leaning people to being more pro immigration. You have to be a salesman, not a die-hard if you actually want to convince anyone rather than just yell at a brick wall and tell yourself that’s praxis.
You didn’t win any conservatives though. If you look at the western core it has been a continual shift to the right. Sure they have their ebbs and flows with their elections but overall trend is a march directly to the right.
Taking liberals at their premise is a losing game.
truly crazy that a single person couldn’t stop an entire society from moving to the right.
How about the entire collective liberal project over hundreds of years, has that managed to stop rightward movement?
There can be no entire collective of liberals. Society is made up of individuals. /s
Nobody has to convince anyone – material reality will do that and climate change is going to kick it into over drive.
The Marxists are just trying to make a revolution happen on beneficial terms before mother nature forces the most painful version of it to become a reality.
I generally use the economic argument to persuade people against the death penalty, because if someone is for it, a call to empathy probably won’t work.
In the last few years, it’s begun to backfire sometimes, because people suggest removing or limiting death row prisoners’ right to appeal 😬
Economical reasoning is a double edged sword when it comes to un or maleducated rightwingers (especially those with no empathy!) because in the procapitalist propaganda which mainstream economy became in last 200 years ultimately it is cheaper to just kill the people. Death row prisoners, then psychiatric wards patients, people with disabilities, and so on and on.
Is anyone arguing that they’re wrong?
Yes this entire thread
There both modern liberals/ neoliberal/ neocon, all evolutionary descendants of liberalism.
A rightwing conservative is closer to a party Democrat than most anyone on the left. Its not hyperbole or anectdote. Its where the philosophical traditions emerge from.
It’s agreed that the core premise is bad, but the point is to cover, even on their own terrible priorities, they are wrong.
No communist/aes state has had an open borders policy.
im sure ñetting cia agents go live in your country is such a wonderful idea.
I’m not.
Removed by mod
The time is coming where very few, if any, people will have jobs. The resources will still be finite and probably scarce. Nobody’s value will be based on their labor.
The value of a person is in their consciousness and ethics. Both of which need more rigorous definition and study.
Yes, about half of the world is of no value.
Getting some heavy Hitler particles from this commentMalthusianism is such a wonderful idea for the right wing, because it does provide them with “plausible” and “scientific” support fot their main sentiment of killing poor people. Despite being debunked shortly after being published, but that never stopped any of them.
fot their main sentiment of killing poor people.
Isn’t the argument in the other direction? If we don’t prepare, the market is going to devalue human labor so people will starve if there is no other way to access resources. To me it sounds like a warning.
Isn’t the argument in the other direction? If we don’t prepare, the market is going to devalue human labor so people will starve if there is no other way to access resources. To me it sounds like a warning.
The argument is that the “finite resources” should only be for those who have value.
And this whole thinking is based around Capitalism which relies on arbitrary scarcity for “value” which is why overproduction is seen as horrible and why there’s so much waste.
I don’t see the should in the comment.
And this whole thinking is based around Capitalism
Because that runs the system. I read the comment as a warning that that must change.
Also a wonderful way for them to out themselves as fascists.
deleted by creator
pragmatic because it’s the only “sensible” thing for white people as that maintains their power while continuously dehumanizing foreign people as dollar signs.
It’s not about the value of a person.
It’s about the value of a tax payer. The more the merrier. Or so you would think, if you believe that other people are also contributing to the society.
It seems to me that the a lot of the right wingers are themselves leeching of the system or avoiding taxes and assuming that everyone does the same, which is why they’re afraid of a larger population.
They don’t really care about the hue of the skin. That’s just an excuse to make an out group that is different from themselves. In small societies where there is racial homogeniety, they simply choose another criteria for the out groups, like the people North of the river etc.
Of course, for some, it’s also about the skin, because racism is grandfathered in to begin with.
They don’t really care about the hue of the skin.
Have you never met reactionaries before? They talk in a way that’d make phrenologists blush.
It’s “talking points” all the way down.
I had a colleague some years ago. Friendly guy and we got along fine, but when it came to politics, he was just blank. He’d take anything I said and go talk to his mom about it. She’d then go on to talk to some other guy about it and repeat back to her son. He’d then bring up the topic later and tell me what they had said. I’d explain it to him one more time and he’d act all enlightened because he then knew how to argue against his mother once more, but he’d keep coming back to me with more talking points and goal moving.
It’s like I had proxy conversation with Satan or something. The majority of right wingers are not Satan. They’re just my friend and his mother.
Maybe Satan is the friends we made along the way XD
I never blame an individual immigrant for trying to start a better life, I would do it if the roles were reversed. But as a laborer bigger labor pool = lower wages so I am opposed to immigration.
“I’d do the same in their position but I’m in my position instead so fuck em, more for me.”
It isn’t simple supply and demand, but even then if you have unions integrating and protecting immigrants then all workers (immigrant or not) have leverage.










