By design, there is no viable route to ending FPTP through electoral means. Vote Democrat, Republican, third party, or don’t vote at all. All achieve the same result. The big two benefit from it and practically speaking, it is borderline impossible, unless vast amounts of people can be convinced to vote third party which itself is a pipe dream at this stage.
You’ve got some states that have done ranked choice. I think the best you can do is raise awareness and hope that politicians will get elected that are interested in a different system.
I get it’s all wishful thinking, but all voting for the spoiler candidate does is spoils things for the party most likely to support your issues.
If 2000 didn’t feature a big time spoiler candidate, would we have 9/11, Iraq and Afghanistan war, 2 right wing Supreme Court justices (that are still there), financial collapse after his 8 years in office or anything else I am missing? We can only speculate, but I for one wouldn’t take that chance in the future.
Dude, the Libertarian party is the biggest third party. That is always the joke about this spoiler effect whining, which despite that fact, only Democrats/Liberals do. So even if you actually believe that the people voting for the third party actually are thinking “I agree with more of Gore’s platform than Bush’s, but on those same issues Nader aligns with Gore, plus he has better consumer protection policies, so I am honor bound to vote Nader despite not liking Bush, if only Nader wasn’t on the ballot so my honor could allow me to vote Gore” or are actually thinking that Nader could win rather than being a protest vote and would probably leave the ballot line blank if there were not third parties.
Even if you actually honestly believed that, and suppressing and fighting third parties would mean every third party vote would just immediately move to the nearest party of the duopoly that actually helps the Republicans by your logic.
I think third party candidates only serve a purpose of spoiling for one of the parties. Whether it’s Democrat or republican. I love a libertarian spoiling Republicans. But make no mistake, their only purpose is to spoil.
If you and I share similar belief and you are looking to vote 3rd party, I am going to tell you you’re wasting your vote on a spoiler candidate. If you are a conservative thinking of voting for a libertarian, if give you my full support. Spoil away.
NO they do not spoil! You have to think that everyone voting for a third party either sees the ~1% polling and agrees with the Elizabeth Warren dead-enders and says my vote could still make it happen or don’t care about the outcome at all. Do you really think that everyone voting Green is a well informed Democrat with coherent liberal beliefs that would absolutely love to vote for Gore, but despite all that thinks Nader could win and votes for him because he has just as much chance of winning as Gore and Nader’s platform is just slightly better?
You have to believe that voters simultaneously adhere to a 1-D spectrum of beliefs, and that is not just a crude appoximation for pundits and pollsters, and are well informed and glad to vote Democrat if one or two points on their platform changed, but despite being well informed and agreeing with you on everything else, don’t understand how voting or elections work.
Either they are incoherent/ill informed, which means that that vote will probably randomly go to one of the other parties, or they are so well informed that they know everything about all the candidates and parties even the third parties that can’t afford ads and can coherently tell you the differences between the Green party candidate and the Democrat and why they like the Green candidate better but never learned anything about how elections work.
OR it is just a protest vote from someone that wouldn’t have voted either candidate anyway or are randomly filling a bubble on the ballot. EITHER WAY IT NEITHER HELPS NOR HURTS A DEMOCRAT!
Do you really think that everyone voting Green is a well informed Democrat with coherent liberal beliefs that would absolutely love to vote for Gore
I don’t think everybody is one thing. They all have their own reasons for voting for who they vote go.
95k people in Florida voted for Nader. Do I believe that if he wasn’t on the ballot that a net 500 of them would have voted for Gore over Bush? 100% I do. And I think if you’re being honest with yourself you would agree.
But beside potentially spoiling the Democrats, what actually did he accomplish by running? I’d argue he accomplished nothing.
The usual point of a third party is to push issues forward and try to bring them to consciousness. Back then third parties might actually be able to participate in some debates.
Sure maybe there would have been some net excess votes for the Democrats. The margin is so small that just by random chance a few hundred excess votes could have gone either way. But there are also the Libertarians and other elections. There is no systematic effect that helps nor hinders Democrats over Republicans. It is just that the Democrat’s electoral strategy to keep moving further and further right to appeal to donors and lobbyists means that they have to have the electoral strategy of them being owed votes from everyone that isn’t a Republican and they should only have to appeal to moderate Republicans and no one else. And under that logic it makes it easier to use the fact that there might be options on the ballot other than them and the Republicans to deflect from this as a losing strategy.
The bigger issue with the 2000 election is that the Democrats never fought or pushed for the obvious issues with the Florida vote. The Brooks Riots were immediately capitulated to, the Supreme Court decision was obviously done knowingly since they explicitly stipulated that there wasn’t any basis to use that decision for future precedent, and Gore just immediately accepted the outcome because he felt it would be more “damaging” to question that there could be any issue with election results or that the institutions might be in any way fallible. Not that there were any non-Gore options allowed on the ballot.
I get that running as 3rd party is a way to get your issues heard and hopefully change one of the 2 actual parties. But winning is usually not the actual goal (unless it’s a down ballot ticket, but even those have limits).
First, this doesn’t sound like what is being proposed by this thread. The person in the video thinks 60% of non voters would come out to vote for a 3rd party. And they would win. I agree that the best way forward is to change the parties, not end them (as that isn’t possible in our system).
Second, how effective is running as 3rd party at actually changing the party? I’m sure some things from Nader eventually made it to the party. If you don’t think he impacted the election, then it’s probably worth it. If you think he gave us 8 years of Bush, 2 wars and 2 lifetime supreme court picks, then maybe not.
I would present Bernie Sanders as an alternative. He was a 3rd party candidate, but ran as a Democrat. He lost in the primaries but has permanently changed the Democratic party. There are people in office today that would never have considered running if it weren’t for him. He did this without splitting the vote in the presidential election. Hillary lost all on her own.
If Nader wasn’t there, the corruption wouldn’t have worked. Gore would have been much further ahead in Florida and it would never have gone to the Supreme Court.
And what good thing did we get from Nader’s candidacy?
It doesn’t undermine anything. Just beecause you can’t prove definitively if something is true or not doesn’t mean we can’t look at the evidence and come to conclusions about what might have happened.
Saying we can’t debate things that can’t be proven would ruin the entire internet.
You don’t know that, though. You’re assuming that enough of those those that voted for Nader would have voted for Gore instead of voting for anyone else or under-voting to cross some imagined threshold where those involved would have been wholly unable to do what they did.
I think we do know that. He took twice as many votes away from Gore as Bush.
Either way, the best case scenario was that Nader had zero impact. Worst case is his participation gave Bush the election. What is the actual point in running then?
The point of running is to push Democrats to adopt issues important to third party voters. This is why Trump made RFK Jr the HHS Secretary, if he didn’t do that he would have run third party and cost Trump the election.
Republicans understand how this works. Why don’t Democrats? If Gore promised Nader the Department of Transportation in exchange for an endorsement, it probably would have worked.
But no. Democrats decided they don’t need third party voters, and they cost themselves the election.
The point of running is to push Democrats to adopt issues important to third party voters. This is why Trump made RFK Jr the HHS Secretary, if he didn’t do that he would have run third party and cost Trump the election.
I think this is saying 2 different things. 1st, you run 3rd party to get the party to adopt issues. You damage the party in one election to show them they need to adopt issues in the next. There’s a debate here on how effective this actually is vs just running as one of the 2 parties and having your voice heard in the primaries.
2nd, you threaten to run 3rd party to get a secretarial appointment? This doesn’t sound OK at all… Also doesn’t sound like what anybody in this thread is supporting.
I think this is saying 2 different things. 1st, you run 3rd party to get the party to adopt issues. You damage the party in one election to show them they need to adopt issues in the next. There’s a debate here on how effective this actually is vs just running as one of the 2 parties and having your voice heard in the primaries.
The effectiveness is debatable, it seems to have worked for a lot of Trump’s coalition, but obviously Bernie demonstrates the other option of running in the primary and then forcing concessions from the Democrats that way instead.
2nd, you threaten to run 3rd party to get a secretarial appointment? This doesn’t sound OK at all… Also doesn’t sound like what anybody in this thread is supporting.
Not necessarily a secretarial appointment specifically, just demands for concessions. Nader’s whole thing was consumer protections, Gore probably could have promised him a reform package or something and achieved the same result. It’s another strategy.
That said? Harris might have won if Bernie had demanded a Secretary of Labor position.
all voting for the spoiler candidate does is spoils things for the party most likely to support your issues.
This does way too much to assume that either wing of the capitalist uniparty would honor the demands of the working class. That thesis simply hasn’t met the burden of proof.
As a matter of fact, there is overwhelming proof to the contrary of that thesis.
By design, there is no viable route to ending FPTP through electoral means. Vote Democrat, Republican, third party, or don’t vote at all. All achieve the same result. The big two benefit from it and practically speaking, it is borderline impossible, unless vast amounts of people can be convinced to vote third party which itself is a pipe dream at this stage.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electoral_reform_in_the_United_States#Proposed_replacements_to_the_current_voting_system
You’ve got some states that have done ranked choice. I think the best you can do is raise awareness and hope that politicians will get elected that are interested in a different system.
I get it’s all wishful thinking, but all voting for the spoiler candidate does is spoils things for the party most likely to support your issues.
If 2000 didn’t feature a big time spoiler candidate, would we have 9/11, Iraq and Afghanistan war, 2 right wing Supreme Court justices (that are still there), financial collapse after his 8 years in office or anything else I am missing? We can only speculate, but I for one wouldn’t take that chance in the future.
Dude, the Libertarian party is the biggest third party. That is always the joke about this spoiler effect whining, which despite that fact, only Democrats/Liberals do. So even if you actually believe that the people voting for the third party actually are thinking “I agree with more of Gore’s platform than Bush’s, but on those same issues Nader aligns with Gore, plus he has better consumer protection policies, so I am honor bound to vote Nader despite not liking Bush, if only Nader wasn’t on the ballot so my honor could allow me to vote Gore” or are actually thinking that Nader could win rather than being a protest vote and would probably leave the ballot line blank if there were not third parties.
Even if you actually honestly believed that, and suppressing and fighting third parties would mean every third party vote would just immediately move to the nearest party of the duopoly that actually helps the Republicans by your logic.
I think third party candidates only serve a purpose of spoiling for one of the parties. Whether it’s Democrat or republican. I love a libertarian spoiling Republicans. But make no mistake, their only purpose is to spoil.
If you and I share similar belief and you are looking to vote 3rd party, I am going to tell you you’re wasting your vote on a spoiler candidate. If you are a conservative thinking of voting for a libertarian, if give you my full support. Spoil away.
NO they do not spoil! You have to think that everyone voting for a third party either sees the ~1% polling and agrees with the Elizabeth Warren dead-enders and says my vote could still make it happen or don’t care about the outcome at all. Do you really think that everyone voting Green is a well informed Democrat with coherent liberal beliefs that would absolutely love to vote for Gore, but despite all that thinks Nader could win and votes for him because he has just as much chance of winning as Gore and Nader’s platform is just slightly better?
You have to believe that voters simultaneously adhere to a 1-D spectrum of beliefs, and that is not just a crude appoximation for pundits and pollsters, and are well informed and glad to vote Democrat if one or two points on their platform changed, but despite being well informed and agreeing with you on everything else, don’t understand how voting or elections work.
Either they are incoherent/ill informed, which means that that vote will probably randomly go to one of the other parties, or they are so well informed that they know everything about all the candidates and parties even the third parties that can’t afford ads and can coherently tell you the differences between the Green party candidate and the Democrat and why they like the Green candidate better but never learned anything about how elections work.
OR it is just a protest vote from someone that wouldn’t have voted either candidate anyway or are randomly filling a bubble on the ballot. EITHER WAY IT NEITHER HELPS NOR HURTS A DEMOCRAT!
I don’t think everybody is one thing. They all have their own reasons for voting for who they vote go.
95k people in Florida voted for Nader. Do I believe that if he wasn’t on the ballot that a net 500 of them would have voted for Gore over Bush? 100% I do. And I think if you’re being honest with yourself you would agree.
But beside potentially spoiling the Democrats, what actually did he accomplish by running? I’d argue he accomplished nothing.
The usual point of a third party is to push issues forward and try to bring them to consciousness. Back then third parties might actually be able to participate in some debates.
Sure maybe there would have been some net excess votes for the Democrats. The margin is so small that just by random chance a few hundred excess votes could have gone either way. But there are also the Libertarians and other elections. There is no systematic effect that helps nor hinders Democrats over Republicans. It is just that the Democrat’s electoral strategy to keep moving further and further right to appeal to donors and lobbyists means that they have to have the electoral strategy of them being owed votes from everyone that isn’t a Republican and they should only have to appeal to moderate Republicans and no one else. And under that logic it makes it easier to use the fact that there might be options on the ballot other than them and the Republicans to deflect from this as a losing strategy.
The bigger issue with the 2000 election is that the Democrats never fought or pushed for the obvious issues with the Florida vote. The Brooks Riots were immediately capitulated to, the Supreme Court decision was obviously done knowingly since they explicitly stipulated that there wasn’t any basis to use that decision for future precedent, and Gore just immediately accepted the outcome because he felt it would be more “damaging” to question that there could be any issue with election results or that the institutions might be in any way fallible. Not that there were any non-Gore options allowed on the ballot.
I get that running as 3rd party is a way to get your issues heard and hopefully change one of the 2 actual parties. But winning is usually not the actual goal (unless it’s a down ballot ticket, but even those have limits).
First, this doesn’t sound like what is being proposed by this thread. The person in the video thinks 60% of non voters would come out to vote for a 3rd party. And they would win. I agree that the best way forward is to change the parties, not end them (as that isn’t possible in our system).
Second, how effective is running as 3rd party at actually changing the party? I’m sure some things from Nader eventually made it to the party. If you don’t think he impacted the election, then it’s probably worth it. If you think he gave us 8 years of Bush, 2 wars and 2 lifetime supreme court picks, then maybe not.
I would present Bernie Sanders as an alternative. He was a 3rd party candidate, but ran as a Democrat. He lost in the primaries but has permanently changed the Democratic party. There are people in office today that would never have considered running if it weren’t for him. He did this without splitting the vote in the presidential election. Hillary lost all on her own.
I would say that corruption, not Nader, put Bush into office in 2001
If Nader wasn’t there, the corruption wouldn’t have worked. Gore would have been much further ahead in Florida and it would never have gone to the Supreme Court.
And what good thing did we get from Nader’s candidacy?
counterfactuals can’t be proven
That’s a convincing argument you got there.
it’s not an argument. it’s a fact that undermines your claim.
It doesn’t undermine anything. Just beecause you can’t prove definitively if something is true or not doesn’t mean we can’t look at the evidence and come to conclusions about what might have happened.
Saying we can’t debate things that can’t be proven would ruin the entire internet.
that’s literally making leaps of logic. it’s not good reasoning. it’s more story telling
You don’t know that, though. You’re assuming that enough of those those that voted for Nader would have voted for Gore instead of voting for anyone else or under-voting to cross some imagined threshold where those involved would have been wholly unable to do what they did.
https://news.gallup.com/poll/2365/nader-voter-second-choices.aspx
I think we do know that. He took twice as many votes away from Gore as Bush.
Either way, the best case scenario was that Nader had zero impact. Worst case is his participation gave Bush the election. What is the actual point in running then?
The point of running is to push Democrats to adopt issues important to third party voters. This is why Trump made RFK Jr the HHS Secretary, if he didn’t do that he would have run third party and cost Trump the election.
Republicans understand how this works. Why don’t Democrats? If Gore promised Nader the Department of Transportation in exchange for an endorsement, it probably would have worked.
But no. Democrats decided they don’t need third party voters, and they cost themselves the election.
I think this is saying 2 different things. 1st, you run 3rd party to get the party to adopt issues. You damage the party in one election to show them they need to adopt issues in the next. There’s a debate here on how effective this actually is vs just running as one of the 2 parties and having your voice heard in the primaries.
2nd, you threaten to run 3rd party to get a secretarial appointment? This doesn’t sound OK at all… Also doesn’t sound like what anybody in this thread is supporting.
The effectiveness is debatable, it seems to have worked for a lot of Trump’s coalition, but obviously Bernie demonstrates the other option of running in the primary and then forcing concessions from the Democrats that way instead.
Not necessarily a secretarial appointment specifically, just demands for concessions. Nader’s whole thing was consumer protections, Gore probably could have promised him a reform package or something and achieved the same result. It’s another strategy.
That said? Harris might have won if Bernie had demanded a Secretary of Labor position.
This does way too much to assume that either wing of the capitalist uniparty would honor the demands of the working class. That thesis simply hasn’t met the burden of proof.
As a matter of fact, there is overwhelming proof to the contrary of that thesis.