If Nader wasn’t there, the corruption wouldn’t have worked. Gore would have been much further ahead in Florida and it would never have gone to the Supreme Court.
And what good thing did we get from Nader’s candidacy?
It doesn’t undermine anything. Just beecause you can’t prove definitively if something is true or not doesn’t mean we can’t look at the evidence and come to conclusions about what might have happened.
Saying we can’t debate things that can’t be proven would ruin the entire internet.
95k voted went to Nader. Bush was up by 300 when the Supreme Court decided to stop counting votes.
It isn’t leaps of logic to say that a net 300 of those 95k would have gone to Gore if Nader wasn’t on the ticket. There’s polling data that shows gore was the 2nd choice for twice as many as Bush.
I get that we can’t possibly know for sure, but it’s far from leaps of logic to demonstrate that Nader likely impacted that election.
You don’t know that, though. You’re assuming that enough of those those that voted for Nader would have voted for Gore instead of voting for anyone else or under-voting to cross some imagined threshold where those involved would have been wholly unable to do what they did.
I think we do know that. He took twice as many votes away from Gore as Bush.
Either way, the best case scenario was that Nader had zero impact. Worst case is his participation gave Bush the election. What is the actual point in running then?
The point of running is to push Democrats to adopt issues important to third party voters. This is why Trump made RFK Jr the HHS Secretary, if he didn’t do that he would have run third party and cost Trump the election.
Republicans understand how this works. Why don’t Democrats? If Gore promised Nader the Department of Transportation in exchange for an endorsement, it probably would have worked.
But no. Democrats decided they don’t need third party voters, and they cost themselves the election.
The point of running is to push Democrats to adopt issues important to third party voters. This is why Trump made RFK Jr the HHS Secretary, if he didn’t do that he would have run third party and cost Trump the election.
I think this is saying 2 different things. 1st, you run 3rd party to get the party to adopt issues. You damage the party in one election to show them they need to adopt issues in the next. There’s a debate here on how effective this actually is vs just running as one of the 2 parties and having your voice heard in the primaries.
2nd, you threaten to run 3rd party to get a secretarial appointment? This doesn’t sound OK at all… Also doesn’t sound like what anybody in this thread is supporting.
I think this is saying 2 different things. 1st, you run 3rd party to get the party to adopt issues. You damage the party in one election to show them they need to adopt issues in the next. There’s a debate here on how effective this actually is vs just running as one of the 2 parties and having your voice heard in the primaries.
The effectiveness is debatable, it seems to have worked for a lot of Trump’s coalition, but obviously Bernie demonstrates the other option of running in the primary and then forcing concessions from the Democrats that way instead.
2nd, you threaten to run 3rd party to get a secretarial appointment? This doesn’t sound OK at all… Also doesn’t sound like what anybody in this thread is supporting.
Not necessarily a secretarial appointment specifically, just demands for concessions. Nader’s whole thing was consumer protections, Gore probably could have promised him a reform package or something and achieved the same result. It’s another strategy.
That said? Harris might have won if Bernie had demanded a Secretary of Labor position.
I think for me, the risk of a 3rd party taking votes from the actual party is not worth it. I think Bernie did it right and has made a genuine impact on the party. My optimism for the democratic party right now is solely that he inspired people to change the party.
Optimism for what? Senate Democrats just helped Republicans weaken the Clean Water Act and Endangered Species Act to build more data centers and pipelines. House Democrats overwhelmingly fell over themselves to anoint Hakeem Jeffries as Speaker.
I would say that corruption, not Nader, put Bush into office in 2001
If Nader wasn’t there, the corruption wouldn’t have worked. Gore would have been much further ahead in Florida and it would never have gone to the Supreme Court.
And what good thing did we get from Nader’s candidacy?
counterfactuals can’t be proven
That’s a convincing argument you got there.
it’s not an argument. it’s a fact that undermines your claim.
It doesn’t undermine anything. Just beecause you can’t prove definitively if something is true or not doesn’t mean we can’t look at the evidence and come to conclusions about what might have happened.
Saying we can’t debate things that can’t be proven would ruin the entire internet.
that’s literally making leaps of logic. it’s not good reasoning. it’s more story telling
95k voted went to Nader. Bush was up by 300 when the Supreme Court decided to stop counting votes.
It isn’t leaps of logic to say that a net 300 of those 95k would have gone to Gore if Nader wasn’t on the ticket. There’s polling data that shows gore was the 2nd choice for twice as many as Bush.
I get that we can’t possibly know for sure, but it’s far from leaps of logic to demonstrate that Nader likely impacted that election.
it is
In a world where Nader wasnt running, what makes you think Bush would be running? you are just writing fiction.
You don’t know that, though. You’re assuming that enough of those those that voted for Nader would have voted for Gore instead of voting for anyone else or under-voting to cross some imagined threshold where those involved would have been wholly unable to do what they did.
https://news.gallup.com/poll/2365/nader-voter-second-choices.aspx
I think we do know that. He took twice as many votes away from Gore as Bush.
Either way, the best case scenario was that Nader had zero impact. Worst case is his participation gave Bush the election. What is the actual point in running then?
The point of running is to push Democrats to adopt issues important to third party voters. This is why Trump made RFK Jr the HHS Secretary, if he didn’t do that he would have run third party and cost Trump the election.
Republicans understand how this works. Why don’t Democrats? If Gore promised Nader the Department of Transportation in exchange for an endorsement, it probably would have worked.
But no. Democrats decided they don’t need third party voters, and they cost themselves the election.
I think this is saying 2 different things. 1st, you run 3rd party to get the party to adopt issues. You damage the party in one election to show them they need to adopt issues in the next. There’s a debate here on how effective this actually is vs just running as one of the 2 parties and having your voice heard in the primaries.
2nd, you threaten to run 3rd party to get a secretarial appointment? This doesn’t sound OK at all… Also doesn’t sound like what anybody in this thread is supporting.
The effectiveness is debatable, it seems to have worked for a lot of Trump’s coalition, but obviously Bernie demonstrates the other option of running in the primary and then forcing concessions from the Democrats that way instead.
Not necessarily a secretarial appointment specifically, just demands for concessions. Nader’s whole thing was consumer protections, Gore probably could have promised him a reform package or something and achieved the same result. It’s another strategy.
That said? Harris might have won if Bernie had demanded a Secretary of Labor position.
I think for me, the risk of a 3rd party taking votes from the actual party is not worth it. I think Bernie did it right and has made a genuine impact on the party. My optimism for the democratic party right now is solely that he inspired people to change the party.
Optimism for what? Senate Democrats just helped Republicans weaken the Clean Water Act and Endangered Species Act to build more data centers and pipelines. House Democrats overwhelmingly fell over themselves to anoint Hakeem Jeffries as Speaker.
Everything gets worse forever until we all die.