Except for nodes extremely close to a HFC hub or head end, the overwhelming majority of the distance traversed through a HFC plant is over literal, optical fiber strands, and with remote PHY equipment the footprint of glass is only expanding. Also, for RF clarity reasons, the termination of the fiber in the street is almost guaranteed to be under a mile from the modem in the premises.
Extending this to claim connections feeding an access network implies the same logic indicates a bad-faith argument.
I have no interest in the legal or marketing aspects of this discussion, but from a purely technical standpoint, it’s entirely accurate to claim that HFC truly is fiber powered, and given the analogue lasers involved, there’s a hell of a lot more power fed into those fiber strands.
the termination of the fiber in the street is almost guaranteed to be under a mile from the modem in the premises.
Huh, TIL the fiber terminates closer than I thought. Though I maintain that a connection is only as good as it’s weakest link so 5 miles vs 1 is irrelevant, even if a shorter cable run provides a stronger connection.
IMO, the connection ISPs are selling are ISP to modem, so whatever the weakest link is between those two is the network you have. I’m saying that if you take the term “fiber powered” for its literal meaning, then you could argue that because the internet itself is fiber powered, then literally any network connecting to it could be pedantically construed to be “fiber powered”. IMO it is not any more grammatically disingenuous for ISP to run fiber up to your street, send it to your modem via LoRa, then claim that the connection is “fiber powered” than it is to do the same but with coax. Both use the same amount of fiber.
Companies are using the term “fiber powered” to maintain plausable deniability while preying on the less tech literate that just see fiber and think “better”.
Though, practically speaking, for 99.99% of people the difference is inconsequential anyway. I personally am on an HFC network and I prefer it over fiber because it performs well, I don’t need 10GB speeds, and AT&T charges 3x the price for a true fiber connection. Though, if the price were equal, sure true fiber would be cooler.
Except for nodes extremely close to a HFC hub or head end, the overwhelming majority of the distance traversed through a HFC plant is over literal, optical fiber strands, and with remote PHY equipment the footprint of glass is only expanding. Also, for RF clarity reasons, the termination of the fiber in the street is almost guaranteed to be under a mile from the modem in the premises.
Extending this to claim connections feeding an access network implies the same logic indicates a bad-faith argument.
I have no interest in the legal or marketing aspects of this discussion, but from a purely technical standpoint, it’s entirely accurate to claim that HFC truly is fiber powered, and given the analogue lasers involved, there’s a hell of a lot more power fed into those fiber strands.
Huh, TIL the fiber terminates closer than I thought. Though I maintain that a connection is only as good as it’s weakest link so 5 miles vs 1 is irrelevant, even if a shorter cable run provides a stronger connection.
IMO, the connection ISPs are selling are ISP to modem, so whatever the weakest link is between those two is the network you have. I’m saying that if you take the term “fiber powered” for its literal meaning, then you could argue that because the internet itself is fiber powered, then literally any network connecting to it could be pedantically construed to be “fiber powered”. IMO it is not any more grammatically disingenuous for ISP to run fiber up to your street, send it to your modem via LoRa, then claim that the connection is “fiber powered” than it is to do the same but with coax. Both use the same amount of fiber.
Companies are using the term “fiber powered” to maintain plausable deniability while preying on the less tech literate that just see fiber and think “better”.
Though, practically speaking, for 99.99% of people the difference is inconsequential anyway. I personally am on an HFC network and I prefer it over fiber because it performs well, I don’t need 10GB speeds, and AT&T charges 3x the price for a true fiber connection. Though, if the price were equal, sure true fiber would be cooler.