• v_pp@lemmygrad.ml
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      14
      arrow-down
      1
      ·
      6 days ago

      You have political disagreements with how the party is structured and practices democracy. You take it upon yourself to spread this article which was specifically written and released in coordination with a splitter faction and weaponized for the purpose of trying to destroy an actual socialist party. You can say all you want that that’s not the point, and that’s not why you’re doing it, but those are objective facts. I’m glad the faction was purged, purges are good and necessary. The vast majority of remaining comrades in fact support the continued struggle to improve the structures and operations of the party that have been developing continuously, on the basis of democratic centralism, before and since 2020.

      • CutieBootieTootie [she/her]@hexbear.netBanned from community
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        11
        arrow-down
        6
        ·
        edit-2
        6 days ago

        this article which was specifically written and released in coordination with a splitter faction and weaponized for the purpose of trying to destroy an actual socialist party

        Marissa cleanly responds to this claim by the Central Committee of the PSL by saying the following in her followup article:

        Even if it were true, it doesn’t undermine the claims present as they’re factual and undisputed by the Central Committee of the PSL. Further, to continue to re-affirm this point despite her saying exactly the opposite is to continue to imbibe the perspective of the victimizer over the victimized

        I’m glad the faction was purged, purges are good and necessary

        True in the abstract that purges are necessary, but if that’s how you feel about a struggle based on whether sexual assault should be handled seriously; I think you are espousing misogynistic beliefs and are a liability to any really existing socialist and communist movement you may align yourself with

        bye

        The vast majority of remaining comrades in fact support the continued struggle to improve the structures and operations of the party that have been developing continuously, on the basis of democratic centralism, before and since 2020

        My branch went from ~40 members to internals with ~8 attendants tops, including the 4 member steering committee. Just because party members remained does not mean that this is the correct line, merely the one which has been enforced

        • v_pp@lemmygrad.ml
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          18
          ·
          6 days ago

          My experience is based neither on what Marissa said nor what the CC said. It’s based on my actual experience with the wrecker faction. Perhaps because that firsthand evidence is apparent to me and my comrades in my (very large) locality, hardly anybody left and there was very little disruption in our operations. The evidence before me is that sexual assault is handled very seriously within the party, especially compared to what I’ve witnessed in other orgs, and certainly compared with what I’ve experienced within bourgeois institutions. I’ve witnessed the faction circulating this article the moment it was published, and seen credible evidence that this coordination was taking place for months in advance.

          As a woman in the party, I have never been a part of an organization that takes misogynistic attitudes and patriarchal violence more seriously. It’s extremely disingenuous to proclaim with your limited evidence and perspective that anyone advocating for anything other than the dismantlement of the organization is a misogynist.

            • amemorablename@lemmygrad.ml
              link
              fedilink
              arrow-up
              12
              ·
              6 days ago

              I’ve been trying to wrap my head around this kind of thing as an issue. The way I’m trying to make sense of it is to break it down roughly into the following groups people tend to fall into when reacting to this kind of thing (keeping in mind there may be crossover and people may change from one instance to the next):

              • skeptics: they are genuinely concerned and believe these kind of issues do, in fact, happen to women a lot but are hesitant to take claims at face value with how high the stakes can be in the context of political organizing
              • pragmatists: their primary concern is disciplined, organized practice and things that seem to fall outside of that are seen as making trouble
              • moralists: their primary concern is believing the victim as a principled stand against a culture that tends to turn a blind eye to victims so often
              • patriarchs: they don’t actually care but find it useful to hide behind the arguments of the skeptics and pragmatists when convenient
              • wreckers: they can take on the appearance of any, depending on what the aim is, but ultimately the goal is to scare people away from organizing, foment distrust, and pit people against each other

              Note that I draw out these labels not as a means of separating people, but as a means of trying to better understand why people don’t appear unified on this kind of thing. And why people can appear at each other’s throats about it, while the people involved in the discussion generally appear sincere and dedicated to the cause. Or why people can appear like they’re a wrecker when they’re being more of a moralist. Or appear like a patriarch when they’re being more of a skeptic.

              It’s not that I think one of these approaches is inherently superior and the rest must go. It’s more like, I think people are being needlessly pushed toward conflicting ends on purpose, as a means of making it harder to resolve conflicts. What drives this splintering, I’m not entirely sure, but it appears to be a repeating theme. Figuring out what’s going on there, and resolving it with some kind of synthesized ideological line on claims of SA, seems more fundamental of a struggle than arguing on the internet over any one reported incident.

        • Linxsan@lemmygrad.ml
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          13
          arrow-down
          1
          ·
          6 days ago

          So wheres this utopian non problematic party we should ditch them for? I rather fix them which is actually doable then even try to reform the DNC or DSA .

          • CutieBootieTootie [she/her]@hexbear.netBanned from community
            link
            fedilink
            English
            arrow-up
            11
            arrow-down
            4
            ·
            6 days ago

            It doesn’t exist; but it’s not utopian to frankly speak about the matters which the PSL faces. Given that no alternative arises in the meantime, if these issues were actually faced I’d much rather rejoin and continue to build what exists there given the sophistication of their institutions; however, it’s all undercut as long as this obvious issue goes unaddressed. If the PSL can not build out the democratic centralist practice to be able to address matters like this it’s dead in the water and it’s better these issues are talked about frankly to inform any other parties or pre-party cadre organizations which have started and will arise as time goes on.