• amemorablename@lemmygrad.ml
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    12
    ·
    6 days ago

    I’ve been trying to wrap my head around this kind of thing as an issue. The way I’m trying to make sense of it is to break it down roughly into the following groups people tend to fall into when reacting to this kind of thing (keeping in mind there may be crossover and people may change from one instance to the next):

    • skeptics: they are genuinely concerned and believe these kind of issues do, in fact, happen to women a lot but are hesitant to take claims at face value with how high the stakes can be in the context of political organizing
    • pragmatists: their primary concern is disciplined, organized practice and things that seem to fall outside of that are seen as making trouble
    • moralists: their primary concern is believing the victim as a principled stand against a culture that tends to turn a blind eye to victims so often
    • patriarchs: they don’t actually care but find it useful to hide behind the arguments of the skeptics and pragmatists when convenient
    • wreckers: they can take on the appearance of any, depending on what the aim is, but ultimately the goal is to scare people away from organizing, foment distrust, and pit people against each other

    Note that I draw out these labels not as a means of separating people, but as a means of trying to better understand why people don’t appear unified on this kind of thing. And why people can appear at each other’s throats about it, while the people involved in the discussion generally appear sincere and dedicated to the cause. Or why people can appear like they’re a wrecker when they’re being more of a moralist. Or appear like a patriarch when they’re being more of a skeptic.

    It’s not that I think one of these approaches is inherently superior and the rest must go. It’s more like, I think people are being needlessly pushed toward conflicting ends on purpose, as a means of making it harder to resolve conflicts. What drives this splintering, I’m not entirely sure, but it appears to be a repeating theme. Figuring out what’s going on there, and resolving it with some kind of synthesized ideological line on claims of SA, seems more fundamental of a struggle than arguing on the internet over any one reported incident.