When I ask the younger devs at work about their code they often tell me what they asked Claude to do instead of telling me what their code does. It’s so frustrating.
It sounds like your boss needs to stop being anyone’s boss. That kind of view is going to lead to piles of tech debt and everything that comes with it.
Does a dev really need to understand the code if the AI understands it?
That if is doing a lot of lifting here, because AI doesn’t understand anything, it only finds mathematical responses to your question. There’s a reason the AI can’t give you the same script twice (or it constantly rewrites the fucking thing instead of just fixing the thing I told it to)
i have a contrast fpr you - there is a younger guy at work who transitioned from more of an analyst to a dev. i work with helping all the devs but because he doesnt have the background he needs extra help. he has used ai more to help him. i have helped him use guardrails and to be precise so he doesnt go down rabbit holes. BUT… after ai helps him get there he takes the time to learn and understand what he has done so he can get there on his own in the future
this is how it should be. it drives me nuts that actual developers at your job have no idea what they are doing
I recently proposed a solution to my boss (who’s older than I am, but not by much) regarding a technical problem we have been having the last few days. He said “that won’t get you anywhere. Ask Gemini.”
Reluctantly, I did. Besides asking it how to disable it, it was the first time I (sort of) voluntarily interacted with it.
It made three suggestions. Two didn’t work. The other one was the solution I proposed to my boss. I told him that (more politely) and he said he wasn’t really interested in addressing the problem anyway and that I should move on.
I’ve gotten this shit from all sorts of people (note: I am not in software dev)
I just repeat my question until they either answer it or fuck off without me doing whatever they wanted me to do, because no I’m not going to waste my time with your half finished work
When I ask the younger devs at work about their code they often tell me what they asked Claude to do instead of telling me what their code does. It’s so frustrating.
And yet, that’s all my boss wants of me. “Does a dev really need to understand the code if the AI understands it?”
That’s frustrating.
It sounds like your boss needs to stop being anyone’s boss. That kind of view is going to lead to piles of tech debt and everything that comes with it.
That if is doing a lot of lifting here, because AI doesn’t understand anything, it only finds mathematical responses to your question. There’s a reason the AI can’t give you the same script twice (or it constantly rewrites the fucking thing instead of just fixing the thing I told it to)
thats crazy yo me.
i have a contrast fpr you - there is a younger guy at work who transitioned from more of an analyst to a dev. i work with helping all the devs but because he doesnt have the background he needs extra help. he has used ai more to help him. i have helped him use guardrails and to be precise so he doesnt go down rabbit holes. BUT… after ai helps him get there he takes the time to learn and understand what he has done so he can get there on his own in the future
this is how it should be. it drives me nuts that actual developers at your job have no idea what they are doing
I recently proposed a solution to my boss (who’s older than I am, but not by much) regarding a technical problem we have been having the last few days. He said “that won’t get you anywhere. Ask Gemini.”
Reluctantly, I did. Besides asking it how to disable it, it was the first time I (sort of) voluntarily interacted with it.
It made three suggestions. Two didn’t work. The other one was the solution I proposed to my boss. I told him that (more politely) and he said he wasn’t really interested in addressing the problem anyway and that I should move on.
I’ve gotten this shit from all sorts of people (note: I am not in software dev)
I just repeat my question until they either answer it or fuck off without me doing whatever they wanted me to do, because no I’m not going to waste my time with your half finished work