I certainly can’t prove to you with 100% certainty that events would have happened differently if Nader wasn’t running.
this reads like you know I was right that counterfactuals can’t be proven, and the rest of this has been storytelling and personal attacks.
I haven’t even asked for proof, since I know counterfactuals can’t be proven. what I have asked for is a test that would be able to disprove your theory. because disprovability is a test, itself, for the scientificness of a claim or theory.
if you don’t want people to eviscerate your specious claims, didn’t post them on an open platform.
Here’s what I’m finding so frustrating about this conversation. I am suggesting a hypothetical scenario where Nader didn’t run and saying that Gore would have won. You are not making an argument that Bush would have won anyway. You are saying that you are incapable of even imagining a scenario where Nader didn’t run.
There is no point in even having a conversation if you aren’t willing to accept the premise.
Thanks for proving my point. You are incapable of even imagining.
The argument is that Nader took votes away from Gore in a way that cost him the election. For ease of communicating, I say “if Nader wasn’t on the ballot Gore would have won”. You chose not to engage wirh the intent of the premise but jump into some science fiction world where Nader didn’t run because Homer Simpson went back in time 2 million years and stepped on a leaf and now we’re all lizard people.
You do not want to have an actual conversation about the issue I’m bringing up.
as I said, you can write fiction all day. but the hard facts are plain.
tell me, if Nader wasn’t on the ballot, then all the people who worked to get him on the ballot, how would they have spent their time? there are so many confounding factors to analyzing your fictional world where Nader wasn’t on the ballot that a claim like “gore would have won” is absolutely unable to be proven.
this reads like you know I was right that counterfactuals can’t be proven, and the rest of this has been storytelling and personal attacks.
I haven’t even asked for proof, since I know counterfactuals can’t be proven. what I have asked for is a test that would be able to disprove your theory. because disprovability is a test, itself, for the scientificness of a claim or theory.
if you don’t want people to eviscerate your specious claims, didn’t post them on an open platform.
Here’s what I’m finding so frustrating about this conversation. I am suggesting a hypothetical scenario where Nader didn’t run and saying that Gore would have won. You are not making an argument that Bush would have won anyway. You are saying that you are incapable of even imagining a scenario where Nader didn’t run.
There is no point in even having a conversation if you aren’t willing to accept the premise.
I’m this hypothetical scenario, have nuclear weapons been invented? is the sky blue? what circumstances led to nader not being on the ballot?
the world is complex and full of people who make independent decisions, often with unknowable reasoning, or acting in a way that can’t be predicted.
you can engage in fantasy all you want, but the supreme court installed Bush. nader wasn’t on the supreme court.
Thanks for proving my point. You are incapable of even imagining.
The argument is that Nader took votes away from Gore in a way that cost him the election. For ease of communicating, I say “if Nader wasn’t on the ballot Gore would have won”. You chose not to engage wirh the intent of the premise but jump into some science fiction world where Nader didn’t run because Homer Simpson went back in time 2 million years and stepped on a leaf and now we’re all lizard people.
You do not want to have an actual conversation about the issue I’m bringing up.
as I said, you can write fiction all day. but the hard facts are plain.
tell me, if Nader wasn’t on the ballot, then all the people who worked to get him on the ballot, how would they have spent their time? there are so many confounding factors to analyzing your fictional world where Nader wasn’t on the ballot that a claim like “gore would have won” is absolutely unable to be proven.
I could just copy and paste my last comment cause you didn’t acknowledge a word I said. So I’ll just leave it here.
you’re right. I don’t want to engage in make believe with you.
Have you ever had a hypothetical discussion in your life? It’s not a wild concept. Humans do it all the time.
You don’t need to know what Nader would have had for breakfast before we can guess at how votes would have changed.
You are incapable of engaging with the premise, so what is no point?
you didn’t say “hypothetically, gore could have won” which, while still unprovable, is more honest.
you made the positive claim that he would have won, and this entire discussion has been me trying to show you that this claim is baseless.