(This takes approx. four minutes to read.)

Similarly to Jewish men attracted to other men, mentally ill Jews (as well as people who were legally ‘Jewish’) suffered a unique discrimination that was in many ways intenser than what us mentally ill Gentiles experienced:

Discrimination against Jewish mentally-ill was extended by virtue of government decree in June 1938, which required separation of Jewish from non-Jewish patients in state hospitals due to fears of “race defilement.” An order issued on 22 June, 1938 by the interior minister of the Reich declared: “Special attention must be paid to the danger of race desecration while accommodating Jews in hospitals. They must be physically separated from patients of German or allied blood… their freedom of movement…must exclude the danger of race desecration” (11).

It was stipulated that the law was to be particularly enforced in state hospitals. This led to extreme overcrowding in the few institutions that were still admitting Jewish mentally-ill. On 15 May, 1939, Jewish inpatients were made more distinct as Jews and required to insert a Jewish first name (Sara or Israel) to their German first name. This heralded a more ominous and deadly practice, a request for hospital administrators and physicians to compile a list of all Jewish patients in institutions, separated into males and females. This was already the beginning of the end.

[…]

The final stage of the discrimination against the Jewish mentally-ill was the ultimate undermining of their freedom and status — the euthanasia stage during which Jewish mentally-ill were targeted and systematically exterminated under the guise of participation in the T4 euthanasia program of “mercy killing.”

While not precise, the Reich Association of Jews in Germany (Reichsvereinigung) believed that there were approximately 2,500 Jews in German mental institutions in early 1940 (3). This estimation did not include Austrian and Polish Jewish mentally-ill nor Jewish mentally-ill patients from mixed marriages (3). The overall estimated figure would add up to approximately 5,000 Jewish victims of euthanasia killings.

[…]

Following the [Fascist] invasion of Poland, euthanasia of mentally-ill rapidly began in earnest. The first euthanasia action transpired as early as 22 September, 1939, with the murder of patients, five employees and the deputy director of the Kocborowo psychiatric hospital in the Gdańsk region (17). While the Polish mentally-ill subpopulation suffered to a great extent alongside their fellow Jewish patients, several factors indicated that the Jewish mentally-ill were singled out and underwent “special treatment” in several instances and were often the first to die.

Thus, Klee states that “beginning December 1939 the first Jewish patients have been taken from the provincial psychiatric institution Meseritz by the SS and ‘evacuated’ ‘to the East’” (6). Eyewitness accounts at the time reported that Jewish patients were boarded into busses and trucks and murdered by exhaust fumes piped into the vehicles or by shooting (18)

[…]

The T4 machine in Berlin began informing Jewish patients’ families or their principal caregivers (welfare societies, Jewish organizations, insurance agencies) that their relative had been transferred to Chełm hospital in the Lublin area of Poland. However, no patients transferred by T4’s Gekrat ever arrived in Chełm hospital and this institution served as subterfuge for T4 to extract money from those financially supporting these patients (6).

The Reichsvereinigung der Juden (Reich Association of Jews in Germany) contributed 350,000 marks and the Hamburg community 40,000 marks for medical treatment — immense amounts at the time (4, 7). T4 obtained information from the hospitals as to who was supporting patients. They then contacted them requesting payment for their accommodation and care while falsely declaring that they were representing the institutions where the patients had been transferred.

While this process appeared primitive, the deception succeeded for several months long after the patients were killed in [Fascist] euthanasia killing centers. […] T4 continued to receive payment for patient expenses from the time of patient transfer until dispatch of these death letters. The Chełm deception was created to fund T4 operations. […] In 1942, the sidewalks around the hospital were paved with tombstones from Chełm’s Jewish cemetery.

[…]

While much of the killing of the Jewish mentally-ill took place within context of the larger euthanasia program which did not target only Jews but in which many non-Jews died as well, evidence does exist that many non-mentally-ill Jews were also killed under the guise of T4 program, without consideration to the state of their health or the lack of illness.

Following spring 1941, this included a process whereby the “euthanasia” program extended to concentration camps under the name “Special Treatment 14f13.” Here, on the orders of Heinrich Himmler, T4 experts were sent to concentration camps to select prisoners incapable of work, who were then murdered in the “euthanasia” institutions (Hartheim, Bernburg, Sonnenstein).

Experts of the 14f13 Program based their decisions on political and racial, rather than “medical” criteria. Mainly Jewish inmates were included and died, without consideration to the state of their health (7)

(Emphasis added.)

I know that I delve into similar topics frequently, but I still flinched when I read some of this.

Being mentally ill myself, I can see how we would be easy targets during an extermination campaign. I struggle with depression, so if I were in Gaza right now I do not know if I would have the willpower to escape any dangers coming my way. That may be easy for somebody who is clinically paranoid or suffering from an anxiety disorder, but it can be very difficult for somebody who finds simple tasks like getting out of bed overwhelming. That is often what depression feels like. I can barely imagine what it must feel like for people who easily trust strangers, hear voices telling them to go somewhere unsafe, or have severe learning impairments.

And given how society generally sees us—as annoyances, burdens, serial killers, or consistently untrustworthy—help can be uneasy to find. This is why the Third Reich tested many of its lethal methods on us first, especially if we were Jewish: few would have noticed that we had gone missing, few would have missed us, and many of us were unproductive members of society, hence why the Fascists called ‘useless eaters’. In their eyes, we were all take and no give. There were similar incentives for testing Zyklon‐B on Soviet POWs first: anticommunists don’t usually care what happens to us communists.

In any case, my hopes in sharing this are to help Jewish people understand how the Shoah befell them. From mediaeval Judaists to Native Americans to Namibians to Armenians to communists to the mentally ill, quite a few of us were on the chopping block before our oppressors turned to focus on you (again). I would certainly never ‘take pride’ in something like that—it is no accomplishment!—but it remains a very useful reminder why the motto is and should be ‘Never again… for anyone.’


Click here for events that happened today (November 19).

1877: Giuseppe Volpi, Fascist Italy’s Minister of Finance, polluted the environment.
1906: Franz Schädle, Obersturmbannführer, was unfortunately born.
1907: Hans Liska, Axis propagandist, started his life.
1926: Giuseppe Umberto ‘Pino’ Rauti, Fascist politician, existed.
1940: Three hundred fifty‐seven Axis aircraft bombed Birmingham overnight, dropping 403 tons of high explosive bombs and 810 incendiary bombs, which resulted in about 900 dead and 2,000 injured, but Greek troops drove Axis ones across the Kalamas River in northwestern Greece.
1941: Franz Halder noted in his diary that, in a meeting that Adolf Schicklgruber held with his top military leaders on this date, Schicklgruber no longer talked about ending the war in 1941; instead, Berlin made plans for Soviet targets east of Moscow for spring and summer of 1942. Meanwhile, west of Moscow, the German 4th Panzer Army attempted to penetrate the gap between the Soviet 30th and 16th Armies which were pushed back on the previous day, but defiant Soviet resistance slowed the Axis advance in the area of Istra.

In Oceania, Axis raider HSK Kormoran intercepted HMAS Sydney west of Shark Bay, with HSK Kormoran firing the first shot at 1730 hours and leaving both ships heavily damaged after the 20‐minute battle. In Africa, the Axis Ariete Division halted the advance of British 22nd Armoured Brigade at Bir el Gubi, Libya, and destroyed or disabled forty British Crusader tanks, but elsewhere the Axis lost the Sidi Rezegh airfield around the same time that the tanks of the British 4th Armoured Brigade engaged Axis tanks of the 21st Panzer Division.
1942: The Axis started losing the Battle of Stalingrad as a surprise counterattack encircled Friedrich Paulus’s German 6th Army, but Axis forces under General Walter Nehring assaulted and penetrated the Vichy defense line at Majaz al Bab, Tunisia. A raid on the Axis‐controlled Vemork heavy water plant at Telemark, Norway, came to grief when the gliders carrying thirty‐four commandos crashed, and the Axis shot all of the survivors after torturous interrogations.
1943: En route to a gas chamber at Auschwitz II, Bina Braun and Rosa Theberger attempted to escape, but the Axis caught them, shot both, and annihilated the rest. Somebody stole the list of 394 prisoners massacred on this day and smuggled it to the resistance leader in Auschwitz I, who then sent the list on to Krakow on November 21 and then to London.
1944: The Waffen‐SS assaulted thirty members of the Luxembourgish resistance in the town of Vianden.