Well, you’re completely mistaken. a ) I’m a German citizen. b ) Russia has nothing to do with tightening and increasing the surveillance, while getting rid of accountability. German history shows that overreach states and omnipotent agencies tend to… well overreach and do bad stuff.
If you need further information and a deep analysis start reading about the stasi.
That’s all correct. However, history also shows that you need a strong intelligence service for it to be able to do a good job. What do you make of these facts? How would you solve these two opposing problems?
OK, do you have an example of an intelligence service doing a good job? We can take turns with examples of “good jobs” and “threat to a free society” if you want.
To give you such examples, you would have to explain to me what ‘good job’ means to you, concerning this topic. Otherwise I will give you examples based on what I think is a ‘good job’, which would likely result in you attacking my notion of ‘good job’, and thus would lead nowhere. In other words, we would have to agree on some kind of common denominator, or everything spirals out of control.
However, if your point was that every ‘good’ intelligence service can also be used to threaten society, then I have to say, I already agreed to that in my former post. I basically pointed out it’s a dilemma. But I think that it is not sensible to have no intelligence service or one that cannot act decisively within a reasonable timeframe. That would be a waste of effort and money, and it would lead back to essentially not (really) having an intelligence service.
Well, you’re completely mistaken. a ) I’m a German citizen. b ) Russia has nothing to do with tightening and increasing the surveillance, while getting rid of accountability. German history shows that overreach states and omnipotent agencies tend to… well overreach and do bad stuff.
If you need further information and a deep analysis start reading about the stasi.
That’s all correct. However, history also shows that you need a strong intelligence service for it to be able to do a good job. What do you make of these facts? How would you solve these two opposing problems?
OK, do you have an example of an intelligence service doing a good job? We can take turns with examples of “good jobs” and “threat to a free society” if you want.
To give you such examples, you would have to explain to me what ‘good job’ means to you, concerning this topic. Otherwise I will give you examples based on what I think is a ‘good job’, which would likely result in you attacking my notion of ‘good job’, and thus would lead nowhere. In other words, we would have to agree on some kind of common denominator, or everything spirals out of control.
However, if your point was that every ‘good’ intelligence service can also be used to threaten society, then I have to say, I already agreed to that in my former post. I basically pointed out it’s a dilemma. But I think that it is not sensible to have no intelligence service or one that cannot act decisively within a reasonable timeframe. That would be a waste of effort and money, and it would lead back to essentially not (really) having an intelligence service.
Supervision and courts. The problem was that the domestic intelligence service had to cooperate with the police to get things done.
The minister in charge didn’t like that and wanted more leeway and wiggle room.
Also he is notoriously known for making laws that get sacked by the courts, because they violate our constitution.