• Jeanne-Paul Marat@lemmygrad.ml
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    16 days ago

    Is it just me or does Soviet History feel a lot more opaque and harder to learn about, and have a lot more just straight up propaganda, than even PRC history?

    • MelianPretext@lemmygrad.ml
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      14 days ago

      That’s unsurprising. Soviet historiography had its legs shot out from under itself when Khrushchev tore down Stalin at the 20th Congress. This meant everything before became both crime and a tragedy. The October Revolution, great as it was, led to the coup by Stalin who stole away Lenin’s legacy. The Great Patriotic War and the legendary sacrifice of the Soviet people and the Red Army was dented by Stalin in his Fűhrerbunker siccing the NKVD on heroic soldiers and mass funneling people into gulags.

      Because this then became official Soviet policy under Khrushchev and was never recanted by his successors, Soviet history was attacked by not just the West but also from within. For a comparison, this was what Deng, who repudiated Mao, avoided by his refusal to do a Secret Speech on Mao and eventually gave rise to the “80% right 20% wrong” formulation which allowed the post-Deng Chinese leadership to have its cake and eat it too in terms of both venting about how they were personally sent off to the countryside under the Cultural Revolution and also avoiding aligning themselves with the West on the latter’s demonization of Mao. That’s why you have all these worthless Western academic stooges pumping out endless propaganda against Mao but it hasn’t moved the needle a bit like their colleagues attacks on Stalin have.

      If the CPC had done that, the entire Chinese Revolution, World War II, the Long March, the War of Liberation, the Korean War would have all been tainted in the same way Khrushchev tainted all of prior Soviet history. Soviet historiography has never recovered from this.

      In the end, this became so distorted that a chemistry teacher, Nina Andreyeva, who had wrote a public letter about her concerns with Gorbachev’s policies was blown up into a Stalinist coup attempt by the CPSU (what a thing for the leadership of the USSR to have been terrified of) trying to reverse Glasnost and Perestroika and this allowed further anti-communist purges and crackdowns, which then allowed for accelerated liberalization that soon after destroyed the Soviet state.

      • Jeanne-Paul Marat@lemmygrad.ml
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        1
        ·
        15 days ago

        Its hard to say exactly.

        But like, take maybe Nikolai Yezhov vs Lin Biao. Like if you look up stuff about Lin Biao, you’ll get the general story, the general explanation of the gang of four and his opportunism, and conflicting reports and what happened when he died. But its not impossible to find a fairly balanced story about what happened, and with a fair amount of sources of internal happenings

        But then for Yezhov, basically the only stuff you’ll find is the western story on the matter, with the general propaganda about him. And then even trying to dig deeper involves digging through a lot more layers of propaganda to get information.

        Another thing is the government of the ussr vs the government of the prc. Looking up how the prc works is fairly straightforward, and beyond the usual anticom stuff you can get a decent idea on the matter. But for the USSR, especially during the Stalin era, it very much feels like the answer is handwaved away as “stalin did everything” which is objectively impossible but whatever.