Ford Motor Company directed workers to be kidnapped, allowed the military to set up a clandestine detention and torture center within its own plant , and provided vans for task forces to abduct workers. This, which for decades was the focus of denunciations by victims, their families, and human rights organizations, has now become part of the judicial truth. The Supreme Court , with substitute judges, upheld the sentence against Pedro Müller, former Manufacturing Manager of the automaker , and reaffirmed the path of seeking out those responsible for crimes against humanity within the company.
The ruling was signed by Horacio Rosatti, president of the Supreme Court, along with associate justices Fernando Poviña (Federal Court of Appeals of Tucumán) and Juan Ignacio Pérez Curci (Federal Court of Appeals of Mendoza). As is often the case in matters related to state terrorism, Justice Carlos Rosenkrantz dissented, arguing that Müller’s role had not been proven.
Ford Motor, of American origin, established itself in Argentina in 1914. In 1942 it had to close due to a lack of supplies, a consequence of World War II. Nineteen years later, in the midst of the import substitution industrialization (ISI) period, it opened its plant in General Pacheco.
By June 1976, the factory in Tigre had 5,124 workers and 2,083 employees, according to the minutes of board meeting number 180. By then, the massacre of the last dictatorship was already underway. It was no coincidence that the emblem of the repression was the Ford Falcon, the green cars in which the executioners went hunting.
Twenty-four Ford workers were kidnapped after the coup d’état of March 24, 1976. Seventeen of them were illegally detained inside the factory itself, while nine were held captive in a shed that was used as a detention and torture center. At the time of their arrests, some were shown photographs from their Ford personnel files or ID cards. None of this could have been ignored by those running the plant, despite their efforts to feign ignorance.
This was the understanding reached in December 2018 by the Federal Oral Court (TOF) 1 of San Martín, which convicted Santiago Omar Riveros, former commander of Military Institutes, and two Ford executives: Héctor Sibilla and Pedro Müller. “Throughout the proceedings, the involvement of the Ford company, through its senior personnel, in the events that harmed the victims in this case has been proven ,” wrote Judges Mario Jorge Gambacorta, Osvaldo Facciano, and Eugenio Martínez Herrero.
In September 2021, Chamber II of the Federal Court of Cassation upheld the sentence. “From March 24, 1976, Ford Argentina acted in concert with the armed forces and security forces to exert repressive power against its employees. Crucial to this was the collaboration with management, aimed at identifying and silencing union leaders, outlawing strikes and union organizations, and thus preventing any disruption that could negatively impact production levels,” wrote Judge Alejandro Slokar at the time.
In late March 2022, judges Ángela Ledesma and Guillermo Yacobucci, with Carlos Mahiques dissenting, opened the door to the Supreme Court for Pedro Müller. The case remained before the highest court for more than four years.
Time worked in favor of those responsible. Sibilla passed away in May 2023. He was 97 years old. He had served in the Army and then was in charge of security at Ford for two decades. Another relevant detail in his biography was that he headed the security office at the United States Embassy until 2004.
A year later, the repeatedly convicted Riveros died. The court was awaiting a decision on the situation of Müller, who is currently 95 years old. At the time of sentencing, the Federal Oral Court (TOF) imposed a ten-year prison term and stated that it should be served in a Federal Penitentiary Service (SPF) facility once the sentence became final.
Müller was born in 1931 in Czechoslovakia. He joined Ford in the early 1960s and worked there until June 1992. By 1976, he held the position of Manufacturing Manager—that is, he was in charge of production. By the time democracy returned, he was already a vice president of the company.
According to the reconstruction by the Federal Oral Court 1 of San Martín, based on investigations such as the one led by historian Victoria Basualdo, in the first months of the coup —and while the kidnappings were taking place— Müller was part of the board of directors of the automotive company.
Ford, by then, through its president, Nicolás Courard, made no secret of its alignment with the dictatorship. In 1980, when the construction of the truck plant was inaugurated, Courard told José Alfredo Martínez de Hoz: “Ford Motor Argentina believed in the National Reorganization Process because it saw in it the vehicle for the country to find its true path.”
Earlier, in February 1976, Courard had given an interview to the New York Times in which he declared: “The terrorists aren’t just the guerrillas out in the mountains or in the streets. They’re right here on the assembly line, threatening the workers and telling them how much they have to produce each day.”
After the kidnappings, the board —which included Müller— celebrated the increase in productivity.
The Court’s position
The majority of the Court understood that, to prove the participation of civilians in crimes against humanity, the historical context in which these crimes were committed must be taken into account. In that regard, it recalled that on other occasions it had stated that the systematic plan of repression was directed against union activities and that there was an “operational plan to ‘eradicate subversive elements’ in the ‘industrial sector’.” Among other issues, it mentioned that, starting on March 24, the right to strike was suspended, the General Confederation of Labor (CGT) was placed under government intervention, and the union activities of workers’ organizations were suspended.
Rosatti, Poviña, and Pérez Curci also drew on the findings of Nunca Más, the report by the National Commission on the Disappearance of Persons (Conadep). It indicates that more than 30 percent of those detained and disappeared were laborers and that many abductions occurred at workplaces.
Rosenkrantz, on the other hand, argued: “Not everything that convinces social science professionals about the occurrence of an event is appropriate and sufficient to convince judges of the Nation. We are not historians, sociologists, or political scientists, who, to explain an event, can rely, among other things, on contextual considerations.”
According to the Supreme Court Justice – who comes from the corporate world – there were not enough elements to convict Müller, and he maintained that the court decided to interpret the evidence to the detriment of the accused. “Beyond Müller’s role as Ford’s manufacturing manager, a circumstance that carries no probative value regarding his criminal participation, the lower court did not indicate any evidence that personally implicated him in the alleged crimes. The case file does not show that Müller had, within his assigned duties or responsibilities, de jure or de facto , custody of the private information of the employees under his supervision, control over entry and exit to the premises, access to specific areas of the factory outside of production zones, or the ability to provide logistical support to enable the military to carry out their operations within the factory. Nor has any testimony been cited from any victim or witness indicating that Müller was present at the time of the arrests or torture, or that he knew about or condoned them,” Rosenkrantz wrote.
The court’s ruling comes at a crucial moment. Just a few weeks ago, the oral trials began against Emilio Parodi, manager of Molinos Río de la Plata, and Juan Ronaldo Tasselkraut, manager of Mercedes-Benz. In recent hours, the Federal Oral Court No. 5 of Comodoro Py questioned the accused regarding the alleged misappropriation of property belonging to the disappeared who were held at the Navy Mechanics School (ESMA).


