• n1bricsfan@lemmygrad.ml
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    11
    ·
    6 days ago

    Critical support is lending support for something while also being aware of its limitations, flaws, and divergence from your own position. Outwardly, critical support focuses on the principal point where orientation and interests converge. The divergence point is usually only focused on internally (within an org, study group, etc). So, in regards to Russia, the outward focus of critical support would be its anti-imperialist resistance and contributions towards the creation of a multipolar world. The inward focus is towards the limitations of Russia due to its bourgeois state structure.

    Critical support is most effective on the collective, organizational level. However, even individual critical support has a positive contribution. Dissenting voices directly challenge imperial cultural hegemony, especially when grounded in materialist analysis. It’s not necessarily going to immediately create class consciousness in every single person, but it contributes to the collective which is working to raise class consciousness.

    Lastly, I really want to emphasize that you aren’t a “disgrace” for not fully understanding this concept - there is no linear path to developing class consciousness and becoming a communist, and each of us have taken different paths when educating ourselves. There is A LOT to unlearn, relearn and become acquainted with, and a lot of these concepts can initially seem a bit abstract, especially if you don’t have a study group to work through things with.

    • sleepykitten@lemmygrad.ml
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      7
      ·
      6 days ago

      What I’m struggling to understand is that am I supposed to join the Russian military or the irgc or go to Yemen and join Ansarallah? How am I exactly supporting them without any material support. In leftist spaces we talk about critical support, but what does that support actually do for that country. I’d argue nothing or close to nothing, except for educating each other and random left adjacent people online what support are we actually giving.

      • star (she)@lemmygrad.ml
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        14
        ·
        edit-2
        6 days ago

        Yes its mostly about rhetorical support + countering propanganda from western media. The battle of ideas is also quite important and not immaterial. Also in organising at home (in imperial core), organising against war with these states.

      • n1bricsfan@lemmygrad.ml
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        7
        ·
        6 days ago

        This is largely an organizational level question that requires specific situational context. Depending on the strength and capacity of an org and the specific moment, critical support could look like mobilizing anti-war actions to various degrees to disrupt the capacity of imperialism. When an org is still growing and developing, actions may be smaller and not actually disruptive, but they provide the practice necessary to organize larger actions once the org grows to sufficient size.

        Critical support also acts as a grounding force towards developing a correct analysis of the situation - where socdems and anarchists reject Iran, Russia, Venezuela, etc for various reasons, communists utilize critical support to understand the nuances of historical situations and how they can be leveraged to our advantage.

        Residing in the imperial core provides a unique opportunity to disrupt imperialism from within, assuming organizational capacity is sufficient. To build to that capacity, it’s important to join an org, learn to conduct analysis, disseminate class consciousness and organize the working class.

        Comrade star provides a good perspective as well.