• Bytemeister@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    3
    arrow-down
    3
    ·
    edit-2
    14 days ago

    And to hold up my end, yes, I voted third party in 2024.

    I’ll admit that “essential” was part of my paraphrasing. Regardless, you voted, you saw a benefit in voting, you saw it worth your time to register and show up (or mail in) to vote. You said “I already explained, to signal to the ruling and working classes that socialism is necessary. Ideally, a socialist party would get enough votes to drive up membership.”

    Why would you throw in with the tankie scumfucks that are actively trying to suppress people from voting to signal membership and increase visibility in the same way you did?

    …That’s some tankie bullshit right there.

    • Cowbee [he/they]@lemmy.ml
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      3
      arrow-down
      2
      ·
      14 days ago

      For all intents and purposes, I belong to the “tankie” group. I believe in the actuality and necessity of revolution, and I support existing socialist states. Those that argue against voting in any capacity as it legitimizes the system, vs. those like myself that see it as occasionally tactically useful in advertising parties, disagree on immediate tactics, not long-term strategy. We both agree that revolution is necessary, and that the US is not a democratic country where voting can get us what we need and want.

      I am not being hypocritical in any capacity, here. I do not believe that reformism is a viable approach. I believe that revolution is necessary. The minor distinctions on how I view participation in bourgeois elections is overshadowed by my emphatic agreement that in any case, the Democrats and Republicans are both enemies of the working class that cannot be worked with, as they both serve billionaires and billionaires alone. We live in an imperialist country, we cannot ally with them against foreign imperialists the way those fighting anti-colonial struggles can (temporarily).

      I am dedicated to building socialism, and this means I am dedicated to helping the people take power for the people. I encourage you to take up similar dedication to our fellow workers.

      • Bytemeister@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        2
        arrow-down
        3
        ·
        14 days ago

        For all intents and purposes, I belong to the “tankie” group.

        If I were you, I would do my best to distance myself from that kind of association.

        From the Wikipedia page for tankie.

        Tankie is a pejorative label generally applied to authoritarian communists, especially those who support or defend acts of repression by such regimes, their allies, or deny the occurrence of the events thereof.

        Being pro communist in the US, or Socialist or Anarchist is not the same as being a Tankie. Tankie is not a shorthand for “political stance further left than a progressive democract.” It specifically refers to knuckle-dragging mouthpieces that spout that “western democracy has failed” while conveniently having a non-stance on how to actually do something about it. It’s not an ideology or a group that will lead to reform, it is mere a cabal of internet trolls trying to sandbag anything that has to do with the actual process of democracy.

        The fact that you can string together more than 3 words and you’ve been around here for more than a few months really leads me to believe that you should put your efforts elsewhere rather than throw in with tankies.

        • Cowbee [he/they]@lemmy.ml
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          3
          arrow-down
          1
          ·
          14 days ago

          I disagree with your analysis of what a tankie is, and who is labeled one. We both absolutely agree that there is a group of people with a similar set of beliefs that almost always get called “tankies” by people who disagree with them. The underlying commonality among the crowd labled “tankie” in common lingo is the consistent support for what are referred to as “actually existing socialist states,” namely the People’s Republic of China, Democratic People’s Republic of Korea, Socialist Republic of Vietnam, Lao People’s Democratic Republic, and the Republic of Cuba.

          Nobody in the English-speaking world comes to support these countries blindly. To varying degrees, each is dragged through the mud and slandered by our education systems, legacy media, thought leaders, Hollywood, and more. Most that do support them tend to be Marxist-Leninists, but not everyone that supports them is an ML. Likewise, someone can claim to be a Marxist, but as long as they do not support these countries, they are celebrated by western institutions as compatible left.

          Tankies absolutely have a plan to achieve socialism. It’s the same as the one I expressed, building up a political party of workers, agitate and propagandize among the working class so as to educate them politically, and prepare for the crisis of capitalism. I am not an exception to the tankie rule as someone who can “string together 3 words,” (an understatement, really, I’m aware that I’m a yapper, and I’m even planning another effort post that will continue to push for socialist organizing I’m just more patient than most.

          Unfortunately, the Marxist left in the west is horribly disorganized, and I realize that I’m in the minority as someone who is organized. Putting theory to practice helps sharpen our knowledge, and makes it easier to talk to people when you’ve been flipped off, yelled at, laughed at, and intimidated by police thugs in real life. Online interactions pale in comparison to that, they just devolve far more quickly into pointless name-slinging.

          The utility of identifying tankies by who we support is because it works both ways. You likely do not support those countries, while I do. You may think them regressive and reactionary, I think them progressive and revolutionary. This is a definite grouping of people, one that nearly always gets labeled a “tankie,” without needing to get into each and every person’s personal impressions of what tankies are like.

          • Bytemeister@lemmy.world
            link
            fedilink
            English
            arrow-up
            2
            arrow-down
            3
            ·
            edit-2
            14 days ago

            I disagree with your analysis of what a tankie is

            If I disagreed in what your opinion of a nazi was, would that change who the nazis are?

            Tankie is pretty explicitly described in the same manner as the Wikipedia page in just about every reference I could find.

            Like I said, you should really distance yourself from the term. It doesn’t paint you, or your goals in a good light. At best, trying to make the label fit the movement has caused you to compromise your methods to garner a little bit of support from a small group reknowned for being toxic little pissants.

            Edit : this guy explicitly extols the virtues of North Korea and defends their humans rights record. Fuck those goals, and fuck anyone who thinks that is a good system to emulate.

            • Cowbee [he/they]@lemmy.ml
              link
              fedilink
              arrow-up
              3
              arrow-down
              2
              ·
              14 days ago

              How both you and I perceive and define Nazis does not change the group itself nor their ideology. We can, instead, choose to agree or disagree on how best to identify a Nazi and Nazism. From Wikipedia, that you linked:

              Tankie is a pejorative label generally applied to authoritarian communists, especially those who support or defend acts of repression by such regimes, their allies, or deny the occurrence of the events thereof.

              This is the liberal, non-communist perspective. It identifies the actually existing socialist states as authoritarian, and identifies contesting western consensus on these states as distinctly tankie. The definition I gave is nearly the same, except I synthesized it with the self-perception of the tankie. My definition identifies both the perspective of the tankie and non-tankie.

              I highly recommend reading “Tankies” by Nia Frome. I own the label of tankie and do my best to be as honest and genuine as I can, because whenever the topics of AES or revolution come up, I am inevitably labeled a tankie anyways. It’s better to confront that head-on so conversation can actually begin, shortcutting to the point where pejoratives are thrown rather than dragging that bit out. You can see the effectiveness here, in that you’re actually responding to what I have to say, even if you may believe you’ll never agree with me.

              • Bytemeister@lemmy.world
                link
                fedilink
                English
                arrow-up
                2
                arrow-down
                2
                ·
                14 days ago

                People’s Republic of China, Democratic People’s Republic of Korea, Socialist Republic of Vietnam, Lao People’s Democratic Republic, and the Republic of Cuba.

                Hold up. Are you really going to argue that the People’s “we will put you in a political prison camp you for things your relatives in another country said” Republic of China isn’t authoritarian? Are you saying that fucking North Korea, which is run by the son of the last dictator, who strapped his uncle to an anti-aircraft gun isn’t authoritarian? Really? Reeeeeaaaaaaally?

                And that is the kind of “Socialist Democracy” you want to bring here?

                Real quick sanity check here, you are familiar with June 4th 1989, right?

                • Cowbee [he/they]@lemmy.ml
                  link
                  fedilink
                  arrow-up
                  4
                  arrow-down
                  1
                  ·
                  14 days ago

                  For clarity, I share the belief with my fellow Marxists that all states are monopolies on violence wielded by the ruling class, and are thus “authoritarian,” regardless of which class is the ruling class. Worker states are also monopolies on violence, even if this is used to uplift the working class and prevent capitalists from regaining control. So, to answer your questions, yes I do support the PRC and DPRK, as the Black Panther Party did before me:

                  The importance I stressed on perception and allegations surrounding the definition of “tankie” is immediately relevant. The idea that the PRC regularly punishes people for what their relatives say abroad is highly exaggerated. Chinese legal code establishes that guilt is only established by the one committing a crime. Meanwhile, Hasan Piker is denied entry into the UK for supporting Palestine.

                  The DPRK is even more egregiously slandered. The story you are referencing is the idea that Kim Jong Un’s uncle was executed by 120 dogs, which was disproven as originating in a Chinese satirical column. There was an entirely different official alleged to have been executed by antiaircraft gun, which, shocker, was also retracted. People believe the wildest claims about the DPRK, yet so many allegations of wild executions are walked out that socialists joke about “juche necromancy.”

                  In any case, yes, both the PRC and DPRK are more comprehensively democratic than the US, and for more on that I recommend professor Roland Boer’s Socialism in Power: On the History and Theory of Socialist Governance. Both have unique forms of democratic decision making that more comprehensively involve the whole of society in guiding how the country is run.

                  As for the June 4th Incident, yes, of course I am, likely more than you given your frankly gullible acceptance of the most nonsense claims about northern Korea. A color revolution grew from what originated as protests against the marketization shifts under Deng Xiaoping that had turned into western-backed protests against CPC control, resulting in a few hundred deaths from clashes between rioters and the PLA around Beijing after the PLA had been sent in to disburse the protests. Once the PLA reached Tian’anmen Square, the center of the protests, the square was dispersed bloodlessly. The CIA-backed student leaders were evacuated in Operation Yellowbird. For more, I recommend this Tian’anmen Protests reading list.

                  I encourage you to be less willing to believe whatever the US Empire says about its geopolitical enemies.

                  • Bytemeister@lemmy.world
                    link
                    fedilink
                    English
                    arrow-up
                    2
                    arrow-down
                    3
                    ·
                    14 days ago

                    to answer your questions, yes I do support the PRC and DPRK,

                    Should have just lead with that. Pretty much a conversation ender right there.