Six years ago, I nearly got my ISP to upgrade our fibre connection to 1Gbps. As I said at the time: This is a curmudgeonly post which is going to look ridiculously outdated in a few years. What's the point of Gigabit broadband? Well, it's a few years later and Virgin Media have just given me their Gig1 package for £30 per month. Nice! With all the inflation related price rises, it's great to …
  • squaresinger@lemmy.worldEnglish
    1·
    1 day ago

    Actually, no. That’s a very simple basic functionality. A router needs to identify the streams (identified by the 5-tuple of source and destination IP and port and the protocol) to work at all. It also needs to prioritise traffic to work at all.

    Combining both features is trivial even on 128mb RAM, and it’s implemented in most routers.

    • WhyJiffie@sh.itjust.worksEnglish
      1·
      2 hours ago

      and what should the router do with traffic going to TCP port 443? because that’s most things going to the internet. it could be video streaming. it could be a video call. it could be someone scrolling unimportant shit on facebook. it could be any of your dozen IoT devices uploading telemetry to the manufacturer. it could be literally anything. you can’t meaningfully prioritize traffic based on just what service is it, you need to keep track of the recent usage of each connection, and that will cost CPU power.

      • squaresinger@lemmy.worldEnglish
        1·
        19 minutes ago

        The algorithm is super easy:

        A stream is defined as something that shares the same Source IP, Target IP, Source port, Target port and protocol, so e.g. “TCP 192.168.0.2:45231 -> 80.0.0.1:443”.

        The router counts how many packets each stream had in the last second.

        If the bandwith is at its limit and two streams want to send a packet, prioritize the one that had fewer packets in the last second.

        This covers all of your bases:

        • A huge download will have tons of packages and it will not have trouble if it gets its speed throttled by a few percent. Because it gets most of the slots it gets lowest priority.
        • A video call will have medium traffic. It gets priority over the download, because it has less packets, thus it will not lag, but because it doesn’t need more traffic, it will not interrupt the download.
        • Scrolling Facebook requires quite low traffic. Most of the content is text or pictures, with a rare, often short low-quality video with quite low traffic requirements. It will get priority over the video call, but since the traffic volume is so tiny it will not harm the video call, unless you have a severely slow connection (<50MBit).
        • Telemetry has incredibly low traffic requirements. We are talking about a few kilobytes per hour. These will have high priority, but since they have such an incredibly tiny traffic footprint, that won’t do anything at all, unless you are on a 56k modem, but if you are you won’t be downloading, video calling or scrolling Facebook anyway.